Not allowed to be Taiwanese


Repeal Article 9 of the Nationality Law

Article 9
An alien who is naturalized ... shall submit a certificate to prove the loss of his (her) original nationality...

Never see your parents again

After giving up original citizenship one day you wish to visit your parents. What if you don't meet visa requirements?

Lose your home

But if one does not give up original citizenship, e.g., land rented from the government, at divorce or inheritance, one has no right to rent.

So we see it is not for some patriotic issue for which one gives up original citizenship these days, but instead usually to apply for land, loans, cell phones, etc.

End up stateless

UN Refugees Magazine 2007/9

One one hand pushing for a refugee asylum law, on the other creating more refugees.

Lopsided statistics

Check the statistics of what groups dare to naturalize. Compare the US.

I don't understand how you Taiwanese think it's only natural to have so many US dual citizenships, but when we want one of yours, you tell us to give up our original citizenship first.

What a waste for both people and government. Just makes lots of red tape. The number of citizenships Taiwanese can have is however not limited.

Dual citizenship: legislators vs. foreign spouses

To Taiwanese, dual citizenship is as common as owning a pet. They only get in trouble occasionally when then becoming legislator with it. Prominent Taiwanese have dual citizenships, but foreign spouses are to obediently play their roles as moms of Taiwanese sons. By Article 9 of the Nationality Law they must give up original citizenship (so that they won't be able to easily run away back to their parents if the relationship with their Taiwanese husbands doesn't work out!)

The same obligations: legislators and foreign spouses must relinquish other citizenships; however they don't get the same rights in return.

Quotes

Taipei Times 2007/09/10

Dozens of organizations argue that unless it ends the discriminatory process by which foreign spouses can obtain citizenship, Taiwan will be undeserving of the UN.

Immigration proposals are worth supporting;

These rules make a mockery of the fact that many Taiwanese possess citizenship of other countries

Legislative Yuan

Ideas can be forwarded to Legislator Xu Zhongxiong's office.

Links

Forumosa: dual citizenship
Taiwan Association for Human Rights
Taiwan Immigration Bureau, Foreign Spouse Hotline: 0800-088885

Etc.

Older more verbose version of this article.


Dan Jacobson

Last modified: 2008-06-12 06:36:46 +0800